Author: user

Posted on by

Discount Brokerage Weekly Roundup – July 26, 2021

The Olympics are a very public stage on which athletes have to be prepared to do their best. In more ways than one, this year’s games serve up some lessons to online brokerages on how to stay cool in the public eye, as well as under the pressure of intense competition.

In this edition of the Roundup, find out which US online brokerage appears to be taking the lead when it comes to innovative approaches for the new terrain of online investing and what it could signal for Canadian online brokerages looking to get creative with client experience. Next, we recap the highs and lows for Canadian online brokerages this week and close out with healthy dose of debate and chatter from DIY investor forums.

Interactive Brokers Positions Itself for a New Normal

There’s no doubt the upcoming Robinhood IPO is going to capture a lot of attention from curious onlookers, analysts, and investors this upcoming week.

As a publicly traded company, there will be a lot of scrutiny on the operations and performance of Robinhood, and a lot more information to dive into on the kinds of efforts Robinhood is going to undertake to drive reasonable rates of return to investors.

While reporting performance might be new to Robinhood, one online brokerage that has become well-practiced to life in the public markets is Interactive Brokers. This past week, Interactive Brokers held their regularly scheduled earnings call, and while there were some blisteringly high headline numbers on client growth to report on, there were several interesting things that surfaced that appear to have flown under the radar that we see as reflecting a very agile move to navigate the new normal of online investing.

Record-breaking Client Growth

There’s no question about what the headline is with respect to the latest earnings release.

Client growth compared to a year ago was up 61% to over 1.4 million client accounts. And while it may pale in terms of number of accounts when compared to Robinhood (which is estimated to have 22.5 million funded accounts), what stands out about Interactive Brokers is that the average account balance is $250,000. By comparison, the reported median balance of Robinhood account holders was $240. 

Even though Interactive Brokers has a competitor offering to the Robinhood cost model (i.e. IBKR Lite), the primary revenue driver for the online broker is still trading commissions, not payment for order flow.

There were two other interesting things that popped up in the earnings call which didn’t get much attention and one that should have gotten more attention but was not covered in the analyst Q&A.

Inactivity Fees Lower Friction to Restart

Earlier this month, Interactive Brokers made an interesting move by removing inactivity fees. On the surface, the move seemed to suggest that Interactive Brokers might be positioning itself to make an overture to some of the clients that would typically not qualify to have the inactivity fees waived – namely, individuals with less than $100,000 in assets or those who didn’t generate at least $10 per month in commissionable trades. For an online brokerage that deliberately sets its sights on active traders, this seemed a little unusual.

Fortunately, this past week, the founder (and still active spokesperson) for Interactive Brokers, Thomas Peterffy, provided additional context for dropping the inactivity fees. Peterffy stated:

“we would like to hold on to the people who have had accounts with us to run them to continue to have accounts with us even if they become inactive for a while. And so, the account is open even if they just leave a few dollars. And then, when they are ready to invest again, they will do it with us.”

Thus, the decision to waive inactivity fees was actually a move to hold onto active trader customers who would want a pause from trading. Instead of closing an account while it is not being used and potentially going to another source to reopen it when wanting to restart trading, by waiving the inactivity fees, Interactive Brokers is hoping that those lucrative, highly active traders will find it easier just to restart an existing account rather than try to open a new one.

This use case is a great example of looking at client behaviour and finding an opportunity to reduce the friction for a client who is behaviourally inclined to actively trade to be able to restart again.

As all online brokerages are aware, active traders are particularly hard to come by, so the motive behind the move for Interactive Brokers to remove inactivity fees makes a lot more sense when positioned in terms of retention as opposed to new client recruitment.

Investor Education Innovation

Another interesting development that was mentioned in the latest Interactive Brokers earnings call was an investor education initiative developed for the online learning platform Coursera. Interactive Brokers has developed and launched a specialization, entitled a “Practical Guide to Trading Specialization,” which is actually comprised of four courses covering the following topics:

  • Fundamentals of Equities
  • Forex – Trading Around the World
  • U.S. Bond Investing Basics
  • Derivatives – Options & Futures

As of the date of publication of this edition of the Roundup, the Interactive Brokers course had a 4.3 rating (out of 5) from 45 participants and enrollment of just over 2,450 students.

In addition to being free, there is a significant bonus feature of getting a “shareable certificate” which can be displayed on LinkedIn. The very interesting catch is that in order to receive the certificate, attendees must complete a hands-on project. And one of the tools that students can use in order to complete the hands-on project is the Trader Workstation (made available via free demo account), which is the Interactive Brokers trading platform.

Investor education was mentioned in the quarterly results, indicating that this feature continues to serve a strategic purpose to better educate investors on how markets work – especially those investors who are newer to investing. Interestingly, this theme is also echoed among several Canadian online brokerages who are investing additional efforts to provide educational resources to online investors, many of whom are just getting started on their online investing journeys.

For Interactive Brokers, the Coursera investor education offering is a very polished mechanism to generate awareness and interest in the Interactive Brokers platform.

Beyond just awareness, however, the fact that users are being nudged to download the Trader Workstation is a savvy move by Interactive Brokers to directly market to, if not, onboard new customers. Granted, a course as demanding as this won’t see a crushing flood of individuals flock to it; however, Interactive Brokers understands that their strategy on new customers is about quality rather than quantity. The added bonus that individuals who complete this course can share it on their LinkedIn profile will advertise the course as social proof and underpins just how innovative this latest move is from a marketing perspective.

As online brokerages here in Canada and in the US wrestle with trying to provide educational content that DIY investors will actually consume, this Coursera offering by Interactive Brokers provides an interesting example that other online brokerages are likely going to be inclined to consider replicating.

Crickets on Crypto

Of course, one of the big developments that we were listening for more information on, which surprisingly, did not get discussed on the conference call, was the launch of cryptocurrency trading on Interactive Brokers.

Earlier this year, we reported the launch of crypto trading by Interactive Brokers; however, there hasn’t been much in the way of details provided since then. Perhaps not entirely by accident, Thomas Peterffy – a notable critic of cryptocurrency – also went on record as saying that he himself now owns some cryptocurrency.

The shift, it seems, sounds like capitulation.  

Peterffy has clearly seen that there is at least some possibility of cryptocurrency becoming a valuable asset class regardless of his personal belief on the thing. Most traders understand that it’s best not to fight the tape, and for the foreseeable future, cryptocurrencies continue to be a part of where money is flowing to.

What was said about the cryptocurrency trading at Interactive Brokers was minimal – the only update we received is that there is more news to come at the end of the month.

Once again, the remarks made over the earnings call and during the Q&A component of the call provide a unique window into the mindset and possible strategic direction of Interactive Brokers going forward. While the kinds of disclosures and discussions are usually well-vetted and rehearsed, the reality is that the occasional hint or nugget gets dropped.

By their own admission, despite the strong numbers posted for the quarter, Interactive Brokers (like other online brokerages) is seeing that there is a slowdown in the pace of online investors rushing to open an online brokerage account and trade it with the same fervor that they had last year or during the first calendar quarter of 2021.

To navigate the next normal, it’s becoming clearer that new features and offerings are going to be required. In this case, it seems that for Interactive Brokers, features such as cryptocurrency trading, as well as client experience features, like reducing inactivity fees, educational resources, and ramping up of customer service are going to be important drivers to hold onto existing clients rather than purely seeking out new ones.

Canadian Online Brokerage Updates

While there’s been lots happening with US online brokerages this past week, Canadian online brokerages have also been busy juggling their own ups and downs.

On the upside, National Bank Direct Brokerage announced the conclusion of the Biggest Winner competition. The ETF picking contest, organized by Horizons ETFs and sponsored by National Bank Direct Brokerage, is now in its 10th year with National Bank Direct Brokerage, having sponsored the competition for the past nine years.

This year, there were 2,620 registrants which, according to contest organizers, was the highest registration since the first edition of the competition. The winner of the competition managed to generate a six-week return of 25.67% and took home the top prize of $7,500. Second place won $2,500 and there were six weekly prizes of $500.

For National Bank Direct Brokerage, this contest is a unique way to boost awareness of the online brokerage and position itself alongside an important selling point: the fact that they offer commission-free trading of ETFs. Of course, the challenge for all Canadian online brokerages coming out of the pandemic is to find creative ways to connect with investors, especially at a low cost.

With a prize payout of $13,000 and just over 2,600 registrants, the numbers from an advertising point of view work out to just under $5 per registrant, which is an exceptionally good deal if some of those registrants end up taking a closer look at either Horizons ETFs and/or National Bank Direct Brokerage.

Even though National Bank Direct Brokerage has been a long-time sponsor of this event, the past year seems especially relevant in terms of the attention that this bank-owned online brokerage has been getting from online investors. And (see forum post below), the additional marketing activities that NBDB is undertaking will almost certainly help in generating more interest and curiosity.

On a literal down note, this past week also saw a number of online brokerages in Canada impacted by a technical outage from Akamai that took down brokerage trading during market hours. More than just online brokerages were impacted, with major banks in Canada, as well as major tech and business names, experiencing service interruptions.

In predictable (and understandable) fashion, Twitter and reddit were awash in acrimonious posts from unhappy online investors, many of whom learned the hard way just how fragile the online trading environment can sometimes be. And even when online brokerages aren’t themselves the culprit, the fact that customers can’t get what they want, when they want it, is enough to leave a digital trail of negative sentiment.

Interestingly (and fortunately), the immediate reaction from investors who were frustrated by the outage were tempered by other online investors and users who posted that the outages were impacting other sites and companies, and this was not an event that was broker-specific.

Nonetheless, the lesson for online brokerages is to be prepared for some (or many) users to take a shoot-first, ask questions later approach to service interruptions. The easier it is for online brokerages to communicate service status and cause of interruptions, the easier it will be for the “fact-checkers” to be able to broadcast reliable information to those users simply blowing off steam.

From the Forums

Word on the Street

When it comes to questions about online brokerages, there are the usual suspects that DIY investors are curious about. Lately, however, we’ve spotted more questions being asked about National Bank Direct Brokerage, such as this post from reddit, in which one user is looking for opinions from fellow DIY investors on this increasingly popular online broker.

Banter Ads

When it comes to advertising, there is simply no pleasing everyone. Of course, if the goal is to generate an emotional response to get people thinking (and talking), then mission accomplished. This fascinating reddit commentary emerged from the recent advertising battle taking place between popular online brokerages Questrade and Wealthsimple Trade.

Into the Close

That’s a wrap on this week’s online brokerage activity. There’s no question that the Robinhood IPO and associated fanfare are going to be in the spotlight. Like everyone else, we’re curious to see where the dust (and price) will settle on the first day, but this is certainly a week for the history books. And, speaking of history in the making, the Olympics are now well underway. Congratulations to team Canada for already making a splash at the games.

Posted on by

Discount Brokerage Weekly Roundup – July 12, 2021

Seems like soccer and hockey players aren’t the only ones working overtime this summer – online brokerages are keeping themselves (and their competitors) very busy. While there might not be any big trophies or awkward press conferences, it seems like there is no shortage of things for online investors to be cheering about this summer.

In this edition of the Roundup, we highlight the biggest small development: the arrival of fractional stock trading in Canada. Next, we dive into a fee drop announcement that appears to be a much bigger deal than it seems. As always, we wrap up with DIY investor chatter from the forums.

Fractional Shares Now Available at Wealthsimple Trade

Thirteen isn’t usually considered a lucky number, but for Canadian DIY investors, it just became one.

This past week, Wealthsimple Trade launched fractional share trading in Canada (albeit on a limited basis), and as result, the landscape of online trading appears to be poised for yet another big change.

Although the list of stocks eligible for fractional stock trading is small, by introducing fractional share trading to mainstream investors in Canada, Wealthsimple Trade has managed to take yet another highly sought-after feature from the US online brokerage space and make it a reality for Canadian DIY investors.

Ever since fractional share trading became commonplace among mainstream US online brokerages, such as Schwab’s “Stock Slices” and Robinhood’s fractional share trading program in late 2019, Canadian DIY investors have been vocal about wanting this kind of feature to be launched by Canadian online brokerages.

This launch is yet another example of Wealthsimple Trade following the lead of US online brokerage Robinhood in delivering online brokerage services in a commission-free way. It also comes at a time in the Canadian online brokerage market when new features and value-added offerings are flooding the market. Given how popular this latest release will be, however, other features being released by brokerages are now going to have to compete even harder for user attention.

There’s lots to unpack with this latest announcement by Wealthsimple Trade, perhaps the most significant being that the die has been cast for fractional share trading here in Canada.

To tease out how the rest of the online brokerage field might respond, it is valuable to look at some context around fractional share trading, especially focusing on who this feature is most appealing to.

To level set, fractional share trading is when online investors can purchase a fraction of a share instead of a whole share. In some dividend reinvestment schemes, investors have been able to do this with dividends but never when buying a stock that doesn’t offer a dividend.

The primary appeal of fractional share trading is that investors with limited assets can still participate directly in purchasing shares of companies whose stock prices might be quite high. For example, one of the names on the list of eligible stocks, Shopify, is currently trading at almost $1,863 per share (closing price at the time of writing), which would require an investor to pony up at least this amount to purchase one whole share. With fractional share trading, investors can now own the amount of a stock that they can afford to buy.

Clearly, fractional share trading is not something that ultra-high net worth clients might be interested in as much as DIY investors who are just starting out, or who have modest investable assets. And that, it seems, is a key driver behind why we’re seeing fractional share trading at Wealthsimple Trade before we’re seeing it elsewhere – they’re deliberately launching features that would appeal to their core customer demographic base. Although the target audience for Wealthsimple Trade is younger and therefore not flush with a large amount of investible assets (yet), the reality is there is a very large target audience to who this applies, which provides the scale required for a program like this to be economical for Wealthsimple Trade.

Another interesting angle to this launch is that Wealthsimple Trade opted to have only four Canadian securities and nine US-listed securities to start. Of the four Canadian stocks, Shopify seems like a shoe-in based on its price and trading volume, but the remaining three choices seemed somewhat arbitrary. Even if Royal Bank and Canadian National Railway could be attributed to the combination of relatively high price and high liquidity, TD Bank – which at last check was trading at $84.70 – is lower in price than say BMO or CIBC, so it is curious as to why the one bank was included in the first list and not several others. It was also curious to see why only four names made the starting grid in Canada, but twice as many in the US.

Based on the business model of Wealthsimple Trade, offering up more choices for investing in fractional shares in US-listed stocks makes sense. Not only are there more “high priced” stocks to choose from to be a part of this program, but Wealthsimple Trade stands to make more money per trade (1.5% foreign exchange fee) for US-listed stocks.

And therein lies the fly in Wealthsimple Trade’s “low cost” ointment.

There is a growing “awakening” taking place among online investor communities that while Wealthsimple Trade’s zero commission pricing is a good deal for Canadian investments, it can actually be more expensive than a traditional online brokerage for US-listed stocks. The fractional share trading model unfortunately does nothing to alleviate that situation for smaller investors, and gives them the unenviable choice to pay a premium to participate on a fractional basis, or to use an ETF to obtain fractional exposure (potentially at another online broker).

There is no doubt more buzz to come around fractional share trading at Wealthsimple Trade. Competitor Canadian online brokerages are almost certainly going to have to follow suit in much the same way that several US online brokers did when fractional share trading went live in the US. That said, until Wealthsimple Trade changes their business model to allow for more competitive pricing to trade or invest in US-listed securities, incumbent Canadian online brokerages have a narrow window of opportunity to highlight their own cost efficiency in this regard and bring to market the ability to trade fractional shares.

We don’t anticipate Wealthsimple Trade’s list of eligible stocks for fractional share trading will stay at 13, however, the longer they keep their pricing for US-listed securities in place, the unluckier they may become.

Interactive Brokers Eliminates Inactivity Fees

If there’s one thing that online investors collectively enjoy hearing about, it’s a fee drop. Interactive Brokers announced this past week that effective July 1, 2021, they are no longer charging the $10 per month of inactivity fees to their clients. News of this move made a big splash.

While inactivity fees are sometimes a deal breaker for beginner or less active investors, at Interactive Brokers, their core customers have usually been highly active investors or day traders. So hitting the $10 per month in commission spend or having more than $100K in assets was not much of an issue.

Data from their most recent monthly metrics reveal, for example, that clients are averaging 500 trades per year for 2021 (estimated from the annualized Daily Average Revenue Trades or DART data per account for the first six months, and then averaged), which works out to about 2 trades per day – a threshold that would handily get most clients past the $10 per month in commission fees generated. As such, inactivity fees are likely not a material source of revenue for Interactive Brokers – although the impact of this move will be something we’re looking out for on their next earnings release.

Despite the $10 fee per month not necessarily being relevant to active investors, for passive or less active investors, the fee was a point of contention. It was interesting to note that coverage of the fee drop made it to Barron’s magazine, and among Canadian online investors, there was significant chatter about the decision to drop the monthly fee.

It is helpful to note that among online investors in DIY investor forums, Interactive Brokers is (and has been for many years) a very popular recommendation among active and value-conscious investors. With low commission charges and incredibly low margin rates compared to peer firms, one of the few things that kept coming up among online investors as a strike against Interactive Brokers was the inactivity fee. Thus, while it is not surprising to see some level of discussion take place about this latest development, it is remarkable that there is THIS much discussion about it.

As it happens, there’s a good reason for Canadian online investors to be extra happy about the inactivity fee drop.

Inactivity fees are one place that TFSAs are susceptible to being charged. Given the contribution limits and the caution against over trading in a TFSA account (lest one catch the ire of the CRA), it seems only natural that this account type at Interactive Brokers would attract inactivity fees (a similar case could be made for RRSPs as well for many investors). As such, inactivity fees served as a major deterrent to investors being able to consolidate accounts with Interactive Brokers until now.

Although it might be a function of the demographic that both trades online and who frequents reddit, the names that continuously came up in forum threads alongside Interactive Brokers were Questrade and TD Direct Investing.

Like Interactive Brokers, Questrade and TD Direct Investing also allow for options trading, which is typically associated with active investing. One of the quirks that characterizes Canadian DIY investors is that they often have more than one online brokerage account – with different accounts at different providers serving different purposes.

With this latest announcement from Interactive Brokers, it is likely that both Questrade and TD Direct Investing are going to see existing clients – especially active traders – move some of their other less active registered accounts over to Interactive Brokers. In industry lingo, it means that Interactive Brokers is poised to win a greater share of wallet.

For DIY investors, it won’t necessarily be all upside though.

If online investors aren’t mindful of transfer fees, leaving one brokerage to go to another could incur some non-refundable transfer fees. Unlike most Canadian online brokerages, Interactive Brokers doesn’t cover the transfer fees charged by another online brokerage. As the tweet below shows, it’s because Interactive Brokers doesn’t charge them when clients transfer out, and as such, IB doesn’t believe they should pay for them when other brokers charge them.

Another feature that investors used to the bank-owned online brokerage experience may not factor in is data subscription fees. At some online brokerages in Canada, data fees are included for level one or two quotes. At Interactive Brokers, however, clients must pay extra for snap quotes or real-time data, which drives up the cost for the casual user.

Despite Interactive Brokers’ largely active trader customer base, the elimination of an inactivity fee will likely have a positive impact on those Canadian clients who have multiple types of accounts with Interactive Brokers, or who have until now elected to not have less active accounts.

The fact that something as seemingly benign as the removal of an inactivity fee has generated as much discussion as it has points to there being significant user interest to consolidate some or all eligible accounts into Interactive Brokers.

As is the case in the US, around the world it appears that Interactive Brokers is squaring off against low-cost players that can attract less active or less affluent clientele. By reducing the hurdle to being a client, Interactive Brokers is embarking on an interesting direction to become much more appealing to mainstream investors than a niche trader-focused tool. In Canada specifically, this small but important fee change appears to be enough to trigger a wave of account transfers, and as a result, we expect to see some interesting developments in the active trader segment in response.

From the Forums

Need Some Pace

The innovation game is tough, especially among Canadian online brokerages. In this post, one user laments a perceived lack of innovation at a popular online brokerage once seen as cutting edge.

Storied Service

One thing is true about social media, folks aren’t shy to complain about what is not going well. For that reason, this post on reddit where someone took the time to relay their positive service experience at an online brokerage, stood out as unusual.

Into the Close

That’s a wrap on an especially nail-biting week (at least for sports fans). Of course, heading into earnings season (again) with economic data looking especially bullish and vaccination rates continuing to creep higher, there’s likely no shortage of excitement coming. Here’s hoping you find a fun way to stay cool and take time out to enjoy a treat (or two)!

Posted on by

Discount Brokerage Weekly Roundup – July 5, 2021

It seems fitting that a short week is also a week for shorts (and not the bearish kind). With Canada Day and Independence Day interrupting the normal flow of trading activity for most DIY investors, it’s actually a great time to sit back, relax, and enjoy a good summer read. Fortunately, the online brokerages here in Canada and the US are teeing up a fair bit of interesting reading heading into July.

This edition of the Roundup features a recap of the latest deals and promotions activity at the outset of July, and what deals activity this month is telegraphing for the remainder of this year. Next, we take a quick look at a huge development in the US online brokerage market: the Robinhood IPO. As always, we keep things spicy with some fascinating DIY investor banter from the investing forums.

Online Brokerage Deals Get Creative

Summer is normally a time when things get a little sleepy in and around the online brokerage space – especially when it comes to deals and promotions. This year, however, things are definitely not “normal” among Canadian online brokerages.

The start of a new month is a convenient time to check in on the state of deals and promotions among Canada’s online brokerages, and this month’s pulse check has turned up some interesting findings for DIY investors and industry watchers to consider.

While there were no new (big) deal launches to announce to start the month, one of the biggest headlines to report on is the extension of National Bank Direct Brokerage’s 100 commission-free trade deal. This offer, which launched in March of this year and was set to expire at the end of June, has been extended until the end of September. On a relative basis, it is by far the biggest commission-free trade deal available to DIY investors in Canada. And with a year to use those commission-free trades, it is also a challenge for rival online brokerage offers to measure up to.

Contextually, this past year has also been an important one for National Bank Direct Brokerage in terms of mainstream exposure.

Having earned top spot in several online brokerage rankings, including the low cost online brokerage crown from Surviscor, and best online brokerage from MoneySense, and best online brokerage for investor satisfaction from J.D. Power, forum chatter among DIY investors clearly shows increased awareness of, and interest in, this online broker. After many years at the periphery, there is something noticeably different about the volume of interest as well as the comments and feedback from existing users.

Objectively, National Bank Direct Brokerage’s price point of standard commissions, the option for commission-free ETF trades combined with the commission-free trade promotional offer for new clients, and the perceived safety and convenience of a bank-owned online broker present a compelling combination for DIY investors. The biggest hurdles facing National Bank Direct Brokerage at this point, it seems, are awareness by more Canadian DIY investors (something that advertising can address) as well as the account opening experience.  

Thus, the decision to extend the deal through the end of the summer bodes well for National Bank Direct Brokerage, as well as for DIY investors, and raises the bar for competing Canadian online brokerages.

Differentiating between Canadian online brokerages is challenging for most DIY investors, so one of the natural starting points is price and subsequently features. With National Bank Direct Brokerage in the spotlight on both of those components, promotions are a natural complement to round out the increased visibility of this online brokerage with value-conscious DIY investors.

In addition to National Bank Direct Brokerage’s promotion extension, there were a couple of other bank-owned online brokerages that had important developments in the deals arena.

HSBC InvestDirect’s 60 commission-free trade offer expired at the end of June. Promotional activity from HSBC InvestDirect has been somewhat cyclical in terms of offers coming to market. Unlike other brokerages, such as BMO InvestorLine, which have much more frequent promotions, HSBC InvestDirect tends to be very tactical during the calendar year. As a result, though this commission-free trade offer expired, if history is any predictor, there could be space for one or two more promotions from HSBC InvestDirect between now and the end of the RSP contribution deadline in 2022.

The other bank-owned online brokerage to cross our deals and promotions radar this month was Scotia iTRADE. Specifically, the modest commission-free trade deal that offers new clients five commission-free trades, plus a bonus five for attending a series of educational webinars aimed at educating attendees about investing online.

With the number of free trades offered being so low (in comparison to other offers currently available), the point of interest here is that Scotia iTRADE is reactivating promotions and doing so by positioning commission-free trades alongside investor education. Of note, this commission-free trade promotion and associated investor education webinar series (pitched as a “bootcamp”) is targeted to younger investors.

This younger demographic of investor is increasingly of interest to Canadian online brokerages, as the past year has shown the appetite for online investing has increased among younger DIY investors. There is clearly a need for better understanding of how investing and markets work that DIY investors can benefit from.

It will be interesting to see how other established online brokerages – such as the bank-owned online broker peers – apply incentives and promotions around key activities (like attending a webinar series). For Scotia iTRADE, however, it is going to be important to gauge whether DIY investors believe that the effort required to attend a webinar is worth the reward of a few commission-free trades.

The bank-owned brokerages weren’t the only ones getting creative with deals and promotions this month, as the challenger brand Wealthsimple Trade also appeared to ramp up its promotional efforts as well.

Throughout the spring and into the early part of the summer, there has been a noticeable acceleration of the use of the “free stock” promotion by Wealthsimple Trade. As part of this offer, new clients (that sign up organically or via referral) can be eligible to receive the cash equivalent of the price of a stock from a pool of select stocks (chosen by Wealthsimple Trade).

This lottery-based approach appears to be similar to the approach used by popular US online broker Robinhood, however, in the case of Wealthsimple Trade, the dollar-equivalent of the stock is provided to the new client instead of a share of a particular company. And, to boot, the dollar amount for the highest stock, Amazon – which last closed at about $3,500 USD (about $4,300 CAD) – makes for a great headline.

The fine print on the Wealthsimple Trade promo clarifies that the “bonus” is a cash deposit and that the value of the bonus ranges between $5 and $4,500, with about 90% of clients receiving less than $50.

One of the most important objectives of online brokerages offering promotions is client acquisition (i.e. getting more customers). In the case of the Wealthsimple Trade promotion, the math behind the current promotion implies that there is a very low cost to Wealthsimple Trade to obtain a new client by using this structure. Even without knowing the probabilities and associated bonus amounts for the remaining 10% of clients, the fact that the average payout is $20 for a new client makes the cost to Wealthsimple Trade extremely attractive.

Despite it being an unusually busy summer for feature releases at Canadian online brokerages, there is also creative activity taking place on the deals and promotions front.

Now that we’ve crossed the halfway point of the calendar year, it is a safe assumption that several influential Canadian online brokerages are already working on their plans for promotions launching this fall (or sooner).

With a massive amount of money invested in enhancements and improvements at many online brokerages, looming competition on the commission-free trading front, as well as a return to “normal” that now includes individuals working from home (and returning to an office), it will be increasingly more challenging to stand out to DIY investors. As a result, like the weather in the summer, we fully expect deals and promotions action to heat up from here.

Robinhood IPO in Motion

Despite it being an incredibly busy year for IPOs (or perhaps because of it), there is one recently announced IPO that is almost certainly going to make waves when it officially launches: Robinhood.

This past week, the popular US online brokerage filed its prospectus to become a publicly traded company under the ticker symbol HOOD (to be listed on Nasdaq). While the details about how much money they intend to raise, and at what share price they intend go public at, are still to be determined, the ability to look “under the hood” at the company’s financial and performance figures reveals a data gold mine to anyone interested in the online brokerage industry in general, and the rise of Robinhood in particular.

Like any prospectus, the document is comprehensive, and as a result, incredibly long and detailed. Buried in the 300+ page document, however, are some incredible figures and statements about the current state of the online broker and what some of its future plans include.

As lengthy as the Weekly Roundup can get, there is far too much information about the online brokerage industry in the prospectus than can be covered in detail here. So, as more information inevitably emerges over the next few weeks, here are some initial figures that stand out.

Valuation: The rise in the valuation of Robinhood is staggering. From its inception in 2013, the company has grown to be worth (at time of publication) $12 billion USD and forecasted to be worth as much as $40 billion at public offering.  

Number of new accounts: The stat cited by Robinhood in its prospectus was that an estimated 50% of all new accounts created in the US between 2016 and 2020 were Robinhood clients. The total number of clients at Robinhood as disclosed in their prospectus was 18 million.

Cost of acquisition: Through the use of a variety of tactics, Robinhood’s cost of client acquisition at the end of March 2021 was – wait for it – $15. That number reflects exceptional performance improvements that have taken place over time, however, it’s a figure that’s sure to give any online brokerage, Canadian or American, a jolt. One of the key drivers of the exceptionally low client acquisition cost has been the Robinhood Referral Program. As mentioned above in the context of Wealthsimple Trade, the promotion of providing a “free stock” for the referral bonus has paid off in spades for Robinhood. It almost defies belief to report that 98% of customers receive a reward between $2.50 and $10.

Revenue mix: There are several interesting data points reported on when it comes to Robinhood’s revenues, but the standout figure relates to the product mix – specifically that options trading represented the highest amount of revenue for Robinhood.

Unlike many other IPOs, the Robinhood IPO is more than just business – it has taken on almost a cultural significance.

While many industry observers and consumers might view the vision of Robinhood to “democratize finance” with skepticism and discount it as marketing, the reality is that through a combination of design, technology, and pricing (and marketing – which they also have spent a fortune on), Robinhood has carved out a space for itself that enables it to compete – on some level – with much larger and longer established brands in the same space.

What was perhaps most striking about the vision for the company as laid out in the IPO filing, was the desire to become the “go-to” app for personal finance, just as Gmail is the go-to app for email and Google Maps is for maps. And, just like those apps, the market that Robinhood is eyeing goes beyond just the US, and is looking at Asia and Europe as additional destinations.

Without question, the Robinhood IPO is going to be in focus and discussion throughout July – which is being forecasted as the launch date for the IPO. To add to the conversation, Robinhood has set aside a significant portion (between 20% to 35%) of its shares to make available to its customers at the time of IPO, meaning that clients will be able to access the actual IPO pricing rather than have to wait until the stock starts trading to get those shares.

From a big-picture perspective, it is fascinating to have witnessed Robinhood launch from inception and grow into an internationally recognized financial services brand worth billions of dollars. The lesson for Canadian online brokerages is clearly that fintech firms can and will come in and displace market share for existing stakeholders. It is already happening in Canada with Wealthsimple Trade, and if Robinhood’s IPO journey is any indicator, there’s an even stronger impetus for Canadian online brokers to pay attention to design and features or risk being forced to play catchup.

From the Forums

Day Trading Up

Fast money and high stakes trades aren’t for everyone. Rare as they might be, DIY investors interested in day trading need to know which online brokerage is best when it comes to supporting this kind of activity. Find out which online broker was a unanimous choice in this reddit thread.

In-formed Opinion

When it comes to opening an online brokerage account, one of the least enjoyable parts of the experience is the sheer number of forms and agreements that need to be completed. One common anxiety-inducing form is the W-8BEN. Find out what one DIY investor went through in this post.

Into the Close

That’s a wrap on this early-July edition of the Roundup. Now that we’re into the second half of the year, and things are opening up again, trips and get togethers will be in focus. Of course, for any hockey fans, the Stanley Cup is in focus as is the cool rink the games are being played in. Stay cool out there!

Posted on by

Discount Brokerage Deals & Promotions – July 2021

As we kick off a new month, the activity in the online brokerage deals and promotions section appears to be mixed.

On the positive side for DIY investors, there was an important extension of a popular promotion from National Bank Direct Brokerage that will undoubtedly continue to attract attention and serve as a catalyst for other online brokers to serve up something equally compelling to new clients.

Wealthsimple Trade also appears to have made some important updates to its promotional mix, pushing more definitively into the “free stock” deal for new account sign ups and for referral offers.

Finally, there was a small commission-free trade offer from Scotia iTRADE linked to DIY investor’s taking a stock market education training series which reflects the ability of incentives to be used alongside key value drivers (in this case investor education).  

Less positive is the fact that some deals have expired heading into July. Specifically, HSBC InvestDirect’s commission-free trade offer ran its course and concluded into the start of July.  

Now that we’ve crossed into the second half of the calendar year, we fully expect deals and promotions activity to start picking up, even more so as we approach September.

This year there’s definitely something unusual in terms of online brokerage activity. Given the large number of new features being released by online brokerages this summer, it’s a safe bet things won’t be as quiet as they usually are when it comes to promotions, and we’re anticipating seeing some more creative offers surface over the next few months.

As always, if there are promotions that we’ve missed that would benefit other DIY investors, let us know and we’ll update our coverage.

Expired Deals

HSBC InvestDirect’s commission-free trades offer formally wrapped up at the end of June.

Extended Deals

National Bank Direct Brokerage extended its popular 100 commission-free trade offer. The new expiry date for this promotion is September 30th.

New Deals

The newest offer to cross our radar was from Scotia iTRADE, who is offering up to 10 commission-free trades (five for using the promo code during account sign up, and five for attending their educational ‘bootcamp’ on investing). This was an interesting offer insofar as it was offering up commission-free trades as a reward for attending a series of educational webinars on investing.

Be sure to check out our discount brokerage deals filter for more information on current promotions.

Posted on by

Discount Brokerage Weekly Roundup – June 28, 2021

There’s no doubt about it, summer is here. While the prescription for most folks is to take it easy, online brokerages have been doing anything but resting up so far this year.

In this month-end edition of the Roundup, we focus on the launch of a new trading dashboard by a big bank-owned online brokerage who is hoping to make strides with the active DIY investing crowd. More new features abound as we highlight announcements at popular online brokerages and some associated chatter from the DIY investor forums.

RBC Direct Investing Launches New Trading Tools

As any seasoned online investor knows, being adaptable and capable of change is a prerequisite to finding new and interesting opportunities to invest in. That said, when it comes to the platform and interface used to pursue those opportunities, changing things around can often be a stressful affair – especially for those individuals who like to have things “just so” or who are familiar enough with the way things have been for some time. Inertia, it seems, is the enemy of momentum.

This past week, one of Canada’s largest and most recognizable bank-owned online brokerages, RBC Direct Investing, officially announced the launch of yet another new feature this year: a new trading dashboard.

At its core, the trading dashboard is intended to provided active investors with a nimble environment in which to manage and execute trades of stocks and ETFs. Actively trading stocks is more time and opportunity-sensitive than passively trading stocks, and as a result, the features required to make and act upon decisions quickly need to be able to support that.

As popular as RBC Direct Investing may be with investors, one of the areas in which several of their bank-owned peers, such as TD Direct Investing and Scotia iTRADE, have managed to outcompete RBC Direct Investing has been in the active trader segment, specifically because of the trading platform experience.

The existing (and now “Old”) RBC Direct Investing trading dashboard provided some of the essential features of a trading-focused user experience, such as the ability to efficiently place trades, and monitor watchlists and level 2 activities.

In the newest incarnation of the active trading experience, RBC Direct Investing has maintained the purpose of the trading dashboard, which is to provide a streamlined trading experience, but has completely redesigned how users can manage information related to tracking and trading stocks and ETFs.

Of the many changes to the user experience that the new trading dashboard introduced, one of the most striking is that the new dashboard enables significant customization of how information gets organized.

By using floating windows, known as widgets, inside of a “workspace,” a user can organize account information, watchlists, charts, quotes, and more in virtually any layout that best suits them. And with five workspaces that can be easily navigated through, there is enough opportunity to track a respectable amount of information quickly and efficiently.

Another huge improvement to the trading experience is the charting on the new trading dashboard. Although it takes a little getting used to, once over the learning curve, there are multiple chart indicators that users can do research with. And, for active traders, it is nice to be able to look for different kinds of technical setups as well as to create notes on the charts themselves. Being able to annotate things like entry and exit points along with reasons on the chart is a big time-saver.

Ironically, one of the biggest strengths of the new approach to design and rendering of trading-oriented information is that with so many moving parts, finding where things are is going to take some getting used to. While watchlists are at the core of the transition from the old system to the new, not all the information about a security that was available in the old version is available in the new (yet).

On that last point, it is clear that RBC Direct Investing is actively collecting feedback on their new trading platform experience, and will (likely) be continuously working to enhance the offering for DIY investors, so this new platform will still evolve from its current state. The nice thing about the configuration of the design is that it is very modular, so changes and improvements can be made without negatively impacting all clients and new enhancements.

In turning to design and modern interfaces, the new dashboard feels more at home in 2021 than does its predecessor. That said, the new interface also has new jargon for DIY investors to have to learn in order to navigate this platform. For example, labels such as “Hub” and “X-ray” do not clearly convey what those things do, which then requires users to learn and remember this information. If there’s an area in which the dashboard will have to be mindful, it’s focusing on being intuitive while at the same time providing something unique to the brand.

Recognizing that active investors and traders have different, and likely more complex, needs and requirements than novice investors, the new trading dashboard is a step in the right direction for RBC to provide these valuable segments of users with enhanced functionality. By enabling a highly customizable interface, the platform experience can be configured by the user and thus change along with their changing needs and preferences. If there’s one thing that can be counted on, it’s that the world of DIY investing is going to continue to change. The challenge for all Canadian online brokerages is whether or not they can keep up.

More Online Brokerage Features Keep Coming

RBC Direct Investing wasn’t the only Canadian online broker making big feature announcements this past week. Three other online brokerages had new features to showcase, which is a clear signal that the self-directed investing space is going to be incredibly busy heading into the end of the year.

All of the new features will undoubtedly need to be marketed as well, so it seems like even though new items are going live in the summer, they’re going to be around and in the spotlight for quite some time.

Here’s a run-down of some important new developments:

Interactive Brokers Launches Credit Card in Canada

Convenience has always been one area that bank-owned online brokerages in Canada have enjoyed a clear advantage over independent brokerages. Whether it’s Canada Post, tech giants like Apple, or retailers like Walmart, the walls around the banking business are being pursued on a number of fronts. This past week, the credit card landscape in Canada just got a little more crowded, and the online brokerage space a whole lot more interesting, as Interactive Brokers Canada announced the arrival of the prepaid Mastercard for Canadians.

This credit card has been available to Interactive Brokers clients in the US for several years, and offers incredibly low interest rates. The fact that it is now being rolled out into Canada is a signal that this program can be delivered cost effectively and with a high degree of confidence. In short, Interactive Brokers has likely figured out how to position this service to its clients – many of whom are active traders – as a way to deepen the relationship with these clients.

While the headline and interest rate will undoubtedly get the attention of financially savvy investors, the details for this card will certainly be a bit of a barrier to adoption. In particular, there are restrictions on the number of point of sale transactions that can be done in a day, as well as limits on withdrawals and purchase amounts.

That limitation in mind, combined with the ultra-low interest rate, suggests that this product offering may represent an alternative to having to tap into a HELOC. With an advertised interest rate of 1.63% (at the time of publication), it will almost certainly raise some eyebrows. In several reddit forums, it has already generated an interesting discussion regarding how and when this kind of card could be useful.

Questrade Bulks Up on Research

This past week, Questrade announced its latest feature category: more robust research. Using “big data” to process multiple input points, the new service for Questrade clients, called TipRanks, aggregates and reports investor data and provides tools for DIY investors to conduct additional research.

While research may not seem like the most popular user feature, in reality it makes a big difference to finding or validating a trading decision. Historically, Questrade has lagged behind its peers in the research component, however, this latest foray into the research pool will be interesting to watch.  

From the Forums

Who Let the Doge Out?

This past week offered Canadian online investors a boost as Wealthsimple added 14 new coins to its suite of cryptocurrencies offered to trade. With so many coins available to be traded now, users on this reddit post weighed in on the expansion of crypto trading at Wealthsimple, and shared what coins they’d love to see become available.

Mass Market

With a clear interest in increasing the accessibility of investing, is it any wonder that marketing would need to be involved? Cue Wealthsimple Trade, who was called out in a (mostly respectful) exchange on reddit. At issue is the saturation of advertising for Wealthsimple Trade and how clients and observers are “not over it.”

Into the Close

Canada Day is just around the corner, and the week ahead will be shorter because of the statutory holiday. Similarly, the US statutory holiday the following week will also slow things down on the trading front for Canadian DIY investors. Wherever you choose to spend this year’s holidays, we hope it is safe and restful.

Posted on by

Discount Brokerage Weekly Roundup – June 21, 2021

Welcome to the official start of summer. With the weather getting nicer, and folks making plans to get out and about, you might be pondering some big thoughts, like where a cow goes on vacation – it’s to the moovies. Yes, pun intended. Here’s hoping all the dads and father figures enjoyed Father’s Day.

Blockbuster features continue to surface this year, and in this summer-ized version of the Roundup, we review an interview with the founder of Interactive Brokers who talked about meme stocks (like the movie chain AMC) and several new features that are slated to be game changers for this innovation-focused brokerage. Also in the new features column, a potentially big new feature – fractional shares – possibly being tested. Find this and DIY investors encountering trading outages in the stories from the forums.

New Feature Spotlight: Interactive Brokers Reveals Big Features Coming Soon

There’s an old trader’s adage that says don’t fight the tape. Most people understand this in terms of the saying “the customer is always right,” or “listen to what the market wants.” In looking at the online brokerage industry, it seems that catering to what the customer wants might be setting the financial and social infrastructure of the world down a dangerous path – or so one executive at an online broker might have us believe.

Heading into the summer, we’ve already observed a flood of new features being announced at Canadian online brokerages, as well as at their US counterparts. Earlier this month, for example, we’ve noted that, at Canadian online brokers, faster account funding has started to surface as an incremental innovation. In the US online brokerage space, this year we’ve seen some interesting developments come from Robinhood in the form of early access to IPOs (likely as a lead up to their IPO), and just announced this month from Interactive Brokers, the launch of cryptocurrency trading by the end of the summer.

News of the announced rollout was delivered by Thomas Peterffy, the founder of Interactive Brokers, at the most recent Piper Sandler Global Exchange & FinTech Conference on June 9.

The interview itself was very intriguing. Contextually speaking, it was fascinating to hear Peterffy’s pessimism with the global state of affairs and disbelief at people buying digital coins on the one hand, while later announcing the launch of cryptocurrency trading (of those very same coins) on the other.

Although he has formally stepped down as CEO of Interactive Brokers, he is still actively campaigning on behalf of the brand, and his lack of enthusiasm about the cryptocurrency product was evident.

Normally, Peterffy brings a clear passion for all things trading. But in this case, it seemed like capitulation to what customers and the market was asking for that led to the decision to launch a cryptocurrency trading offering. One of the formal challenges he cited was ensuring that the trading of cryptocurrencies would be 100% safe – something he deferred providing details into until the product launch at the end of the summer.

While the news of a new product offering launch is big, Peterffy also dropped a hint of another feature announcement that is “coming soon.”

When asked about the way in which the impact of the global pandemic affected customer service, Peterffy revealed that automation was the key to solving many problems, but it could not solve all of them. His answer to discussing customer service was positioned from the perspective of the business itself, breaking down the need for customers to access speaking to an agent in terms of dollars per hour spent on servicing a client.

In the final analysis, Peterffy’s view was that it should not cost more to service the client than the client is worth to the firm. And, it was at that point that he revealed that Interactive Brokers is working on something interesting related to client service, and potentially something that could bring down the cost of servicing clients.

There were several other really interesting nuggets revealed by Peterffy as to the direction and position of Interactive Brokers on a number of fronts, but the final one to highlight was his response to new account growth and what the future may hold for Interactive Brokers.

Specifically, as we’ve noted in the Roundup last month, there has been a consistent and significant downward trend in the number of new accounts being opened this year at Interactive Brokers since the numbers peaked in January. The graph below illustrates this trend, and based on the numbers from May, this is the fourth consecutive month over month decline in the net new account growth. Although there were just over 26,000 net new accounts opened at Interactive Brokers in May, this represented just shy of a 24% decline compared to the number of new accounts opened in April, and reflects a drop of just about 78% from the number of net new accounts opened in January.

Peterffy’s take on what drives new account growth was especially noteworthy. In his response, he stated that the biggest source of new clients at Interactive Brokers is through referrals – somewhere in the neighbourhood of 33%. Regardless of what channel a new client comes in from, the fascinating thing, according to Peterffy, is that the percentages from the sources remain about the same. So, what ultimately drives online investors into opening an online brokerage account is the “buzz” around what’s hot in the markets, and as it turns out, consumers will choose or consider an online brokerage that they’re familiar with. The implications of this revelations are really important – it suggests that online brokerages would be better off continuously advertising. However, the real advantage for doing so would emerge when a “hot” story drives online investors to market.

Although the interview with Peterffy was relatively short, there was a wealth (pun intended) of insights related to investing online. The pessimism about the global and financial state of affairs for online investors was palpable, and summarized by the following statement he made:

“We’ve completely lost our grounding, we’ve become unhinged, nobody knows what our values are, we are floating and hope we land right side up.”

The context of these comments generally center around what investors today are piling into – such as meme stocks – and that the shortcomings of the regulatory frameworks that are currently in place for investors are being laid bare by online investor “armies” that have shown the ability to push back against larger institutional players. This pessimism is worth paying attention to, however, as the domino effect of losses in the meme stocks has a possibility (and a likely one suggested by Peterffy) to be catastrophic.

In the meanwhile, the big picture takeaway from Peterffy’s comments is that whether or not he likes it, everyone, including online brokerages, will have to confront a brave new world of “investing.” That means preparing technical systems for wild volatility. And for other online brokerages hoping to push their own growth agenda, it means being ever visible in anticipation of when the next big thing hits. Because, when it does, that’s when investors will really start to pay attention.

From the Forums

Wealthsimple Testing Fractional Shares?

Online brokerages continue to push new features out this year, however, some may be dropping hints before they go completely live. If this new feature from Wealthsimple Trade turns out to be true, it is yet another possible game changing feature that will undoubtedly capture the interest of DIY investors. According to this reddit post, Wealthsimple Trade is apparently piloting fractional share trading on select securities. While it may be too early to trade in fractions of a share, the presence of a fractional trading tag is raising more than a few eyebrows among DIY investors. And, if true, it will undoubtedly push other Canadian online brokerages to move even faster to deliver innovative offerings for investors.

Stability Now

It’s been a tough month for system and trading outages at Canadian bank-owned online brokerages. Earlier this month, TD Direct Investing had an outage during market hours, and this past week, CIBC Investor’s Edge users suffered a trading outage during market hours. Angry clients took to social media to vent their frustration and provide a clear picture of what DIY investors think when an online brokerage system goes offline during the trading day. Check out what investors had to say in this reddit post.

Into the Close

This week, we’d like to call special attention to Indigenous People’s Day which recognizes the heritage, diverse cultures, and achievements of First Nations, Inuit and Métis peoples. It is our hope that readers make some time to reflect on the history of the Indigenous peoples in Canada, as hard as it may be, and be an advocate for a building a better future. An important starting point is the Final Report of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada.

Posted on by

Discount Brokerage Weekly Roundup – June 7, 2021

With warmer weather around the corner, it looks like the Leafs may actually have some fans this summer after all. Couldn’t resist. Fortunately, it’s still spring and the theme of new beginnings and growth are very much in focus among Canadian online brokerages.

In this edition of the Roundup, new is en vogue. First, we take a look at the newest online brokerage deals and promotions, including an interesting development at one already popular online broker that’s sure to spur others into action. Next, we highlight the latest new blockbuster feature being launched by an online brokerage this season. To cap things off, we provide chatter from the investor forums reacting to scary glitches and instant deposits.

New Month, New Deals

And just like that, summer is only a few weeks away. June is now upon us, and with the start of a new month comes a chance to check in on the status of the deals and promotions being offered at Canada’s online brokerages.

This month, it’s a good news, bad news story for DIY investors on the hunt for a promotional bump. The good news is that there wasn’t a drop in the number of promotions, and there are signs that one of Canada’s increasingly popular online brokerages isn’t afraid to commit to promotions as a way to attract the attention of new clients. The not-so-great news for online investors is that after June, there are a pair of promotions that are scheduled to expire, which means that even though there is a good chance more deals are on their way, the exact timing isn’t clear.

Starting first with a quick scan of the current promotional picture, BMO InvestorLine had a new cash back promotion that launched on June 2nd to replace its outgoing cash back offer that expired on June 1st.

The new cash back promotion from BMO InvestorLine is very similar to the one that it replaced in that it’s a tiered promotion that offers increasing amounts of cash back bonuses as the amount deposited increases. The important difference with the new offer is that minimum deposit required to qualify for this promotion dropped from $25,000 to $15,000, a significantly lower amount.

The latest BMO InvestorLine promotion runs until August 31st and features cash back amounts ranging from $50 (for deposits of $15,000 to $49,999) to $2,000 (for deposits of $1M+).

Although not new this month, Wealthsimple Trade is now also part of the deals and promotions mix in a major way. In May they launched a “free stock” promotion for new cash account clients to receive a cash bonus in the equivalent amount of a stock chosen at random from a selection of eligible stocks.

Marketed to online investors as a “free stock” promo, this offer has garnered quite a bit of attention online. It also appears that this promotional offer has been so successful through several trial runs that a recent note from Wealthsimple Trade about its referral promotion indicates that it too will be switching to a “free stock” compensation model.

With Wealthsimple Trade joining in the deals and promotions pool at a time when most online brokerages are electing to stand on the sidelines, it appears to be open field for the newcomer online brokerage at a time when meme stock excitement has resurfaced.

Contextually, this poses a challenge for two other online brokerages with commission-free trading offers that expire at the end of the month.

National Bank Direct Brokerage’s massive 100 commission-free trade offer and HSBC InvestDirect’s 60 commission-free trade promotion are both set to expire by the end of June. National Bank Direct Brokerage has seen a boost to its publicity across Canada as it scored first place in a recent Surviscor ranking of online brokerages, as well as scoring first place in the J.D. Power Investor Satisfaction Study. Also, National Bank Direct Brokerage just launched their annual “Biggest Winner” ETF competition at the end of May, putting yet another spotlight onto this online broker.

The challenge posed by the entry of Wealthsimple Trade into the deals and promotion mix is that those brokerages with existing commission-free trade offers may want to consider extending them, or replacing them with even more competitive cash back bonuses.

Unlike the Big Five bank-owned online brokerages, National Bank Direct Brokerage and HSBC InvestDirect do not have the level of awareness or scale that their larger bank-owned brokerage competitors enjoy, despite being “bank owned.” Conversely, neither of these two bank-owned online brokerages are as well known as some of the “independent” brokerages known for lower cost trading – such as Questrade and Wealthsimple Trade.

Thus, if promotional offers are a low-cost tool used to boost awareness, either extending or launching new offers may be a way to stay relevant and competitive across the summer. With meme stocks and cryptocurrency trading still bubbling away, younger investors are continuing to take note. And while that is generally good for all online brokerages, those online brokers with highly competitive offers will undoubtedly find themselves being considered and recommended for deep value for growth-minded investors.  

Summer Blockbusters are Back

Grab a meme stock and some free popcorn, because it looks like the summer of blockbuster announcements from online brokerages is here.

After a frothy start to markets this year, it seems that Canadian online brokerages are now the ones that are going to be in the spotlight when it comes to making big announcements.

In April and May, there were some significant new features launched by RBC Direct Investing and Wealthsimple Trade. Two weeks ago, BMO InvestorLine announced it was launching commission-free ETF trading on a selection of more than 80 ETFs. 

This past week it was Questrade’s turn.

In what seems like a direct shot across the bow to Wealthsimple Trade’s account funding time, Questrade announced, courtesy of a partnership with fintech startup Zum, that clients can now fund their accounts instantly using Visa Debit, with up to $3,500. By comparison, Wealthsimple Trade enables users to deposit only $250 instantly, or for those willing to pay $3 per month for Wealthsimple Trade premium, the amount rises to $1,000.

The blockbuster features haven’t been limited to Canada either. In the US online brokerage space, Robinhood announced in late May that it is launching a new feature enabling investors to participate in IPOs at the IPO price, rather than having to wait to purchase the security once it hits the open market. This is a huge development for retail investors who have typically been unable to tap into the massive gains that certain IPOs experience, because the investors were not connected to institutional investors or perhaps not wealthy enough to be given early access.

The US online brokerage market is an important proxy for what the world of DIY investing looks like when commission rates all but fall to zero.

What has been clear at online brokerages such as Robinhood, Schwab/Ameritrade, and others is that features and user experience tend to become areas of focus and innovation. Granted, how US online brokerages can monetize zero-commission trading is different than it is here in Canada. However, the likelihood that commissions stay at $9.95 as the standard price for much longer is low. In addition, even those online brokerages with lower commissions can’t stand still when it comes to innovation – they have to keep delivering better experiences to investors because other online brokerages will. (And new online brokerages are still coming to Canada, to boot.)

We’ve already witnessed a number of online brokerages concede ground on charging commissions for trading ETFs, either in part or entirely. As the Globe and Mail’s Rob Carrick put it in a recent article, “We now have some real momentum in getting rid of ETF trading commissions… There are now at least eight online brokers and trading apps that have at least partly eliminated the cost of buying and selling ETFs.” Given how popular ETFs are with online investors, the writing is on the wall at the remaining online brokerages that do not at least match if not beat this new ETF pricing paradigm.

And, as popular as ETFs are, Questrade’s launch of instant account funding clearly strikes at a nerve for DIY investors who want to be able to enjoy instantly jumping into opportunities. Friction, not change, is the new dirty word in technology conversations among financial services providers, and especially incumbent players in the online brokerage world. Instant account opening and funding are frontiers where too many Canadian online brokerages still fall short in the eyes of online investors. Based on Questrade’s latest push to enable instant funding of up to $3,500, they won’t be the last online broker to launch this feature. Several business days is an eternity when meme stock movements strike.

The merits and wisdom of trading fast-moving stocks aside, the reality is that investor behaviour during COVID-19 has shown that certain categories of investors have a very different risk appetite for trading volatility. Online brokerages who can reduce the friction between getting started and participating in exciting stories are themselves going to become the exciting stories that online investors talk about. And that conversation is now worth its weight in digital gold.

From the Forums

Care to Share?

It almost seems trivial, but expecting your online brokerage account view to display the correct information should be a given. Many clients of Wealthsimple Trade found out the hard way, however, that when it comes to online investing, just about anything can go wrong – including what should be the basic stuff. Check out what redditors had to say here and here about technical glitches that left clients scratching their heads at the data they were seeing in their account summaries.

Instant Gratification

One of the biggest stories to get online investors chatting this month (so far) was the launch of instant deposits at Questrade. Interestingly (and is usually the case), the discussions deviated from the new feature to cover issues with existing features, challenges other brokerages might face, and investor preferences when it comes to trading online. Read through the reactions here and here.

Into the Close

That’s a wrap on another semi-short week courtesy of a long weekend in the US. Of course, for Leafs fans it certainly felt a lot longer. Again, couldn’t resist. There’s still lots on the radar for online investors that we didn’t get a chance to dive into, so stay tuned for more updates on the DIY investor data-palooza coming next week, and updates on more new features we didn’t have a chance to discuss this go-around. With stock markets at or near new all time highs, meme stocks making a comeback, and crypto now in the doge-house with investors, there’s almost certainly a plot twist in the making coming soon. Have a profitable week ahead!

Posted on by

Discount Brokerage Deals & Promotions – June 2021

We’re officially in the home stretch to start of summer and like temperatures, we believe that online brokerage deals activity is slated to rise as the month progresses. For the moment, however, most Canadian online brokerages continue to take it easy.

Just because we’re not seeing a flood of online brokerage deals coming to market yet, however, does not mean that activity isn’t taking place behind the scenes.

In a world where unusual is the new normal, signals abound that the wave of investor enthusiasm that started the year (and that has characterized the past 12 months) is continuing to recede taking with it the volume of activity of new account opening at Canadian online brokerages. This is a net-positive for deal-seeking online investors because as investor supply decreases, online brokerages will necessarily look to new promotions as an option to attract new customers.

Another unusual development heading into the new month is deals activity at one of Canada’s newer online brokers – Wealthsimple Trade.

Having garnered a massive early interest based on zero-dollar commissions, this rapidly growing online broker has dialed up its affiliate promotion structure as well as using free stock and cash back offers (see below for more details). The result is armies of affiliate-revenue seeking amplifying Wealthsimple Trade to the broader public at a fraction of the cost that the competitors to Wealthsimple Trade are paying.

Thus, the costs of standing still on the deals and promotions front are not only starting add up for those online brokerages without some kind of campaign in place, they’re actually beginning to compound.

As we launch into a new month, it is worth pointing out that two promotions are set to expire at the end of June. National Bank Direct Brokerage’s huge commission-free trade offer as well as a commission-free trade promo by HSBC InvestDirect are both scheduled to conclude by month’s end.

Head over to the deals and promotions section to review the latest online brokerage offers and as always if there are any promotions for DIY investors that we’ve missed, let us know and we can update our deals section.

Expired Deals

As of the publication of the deals update, the only promotion that had technically expired was the spring cash back promotion from BMO InvestorLine. While it is often the case that BMO InvestorLine has offers for new accounts running throughout the year, they also just launched a slate of commission-free ETFs that is only beginning to be advertised. We’ll keep watching for updates to their promotional offers for any new offers that show up.

Extended Deals

No deal extensions to mention at this time

New Deals

Wealthsimple Trade added a “free stock” bonus promo to new users of the platform. This offer randomly selects stocks valued between $5 and $4,500 and new users are eligible to receive a cash bonus equal to the value of the stock from the pool of eligible stocks when they open a new non-registered account. According to the terms and conditions of the offer, about 90% of new clients receive a cash bonus offer worth less $50. There is no expiry date stated for this promotion.

Posted on by

Discount Brokerage Weekly Roundup – May 31, 2021

It’s Memorial Day weekend in the US, which means that markets there are closed. Here in Canada, however, despite it being a short week last week, the volume of newsworthy developments was quite hefty. There’s lots to catch up on.

In this edition of the Roundup, we look at a big Canadian online brokerage making a splash by jumping into commission-free ETFs. From there, we continue to plumb the depths of more DIY investor data with an important online brokerage rankings release. As always, we cap things off with a snapshot of investor chatter from the DIY investing forums.

BMO InvestorLine Launches Commission-Free ETF Trading

Every now and then a tipping point development takes place in the Canadian online brokerage space. This past week, we might have just witnessed another important milestone in the price reduction for DIY investors.

News started to spread among DIY investors that BMO InvestorLine has launched commission-free ETF trading for a list of 80 ETFs.

This is clearly a big deal given the prominence of BMO InvestorLine in the Canadian online brokerage landscape. And, while they are not the biggest or most popular online brokerage, they do command a respectable amount of attention in online brokerage rankings, and they are part of the “Big Five” bank-owned online brokerages.

Commission-free ETFs at Canadian online brokerages are neither novel nor are they new to Big Five banks either.

Scotia iTRADE, for example, has a list of 49 (as of the date of publication). However, they launched this feature back in 2011 – almost ten years ago – and were followed by Qtrade (with a list of 100 commission-free ETFs) and Virtual Brokers in 2012.

National Bank Direct Brokerage also offers commission-free ETF buying and selling on all ETFs (Canadian and US) so long as minimum purchase amounts are met (minimum 100 units). And, for good measure, Questrade and Virtual Brokers offer commission-free buying of ETFs. Not to mention Wealthsimple Trade, where all Canadian ETFs can be traded commission-free.

Thus, BMO InvestorLine is not the first to jump into the pool by any means, but their offer is already making a splash among DIY investors, who are reacting with the same enthusiasm they did almost a decade ago when these free offerings first hit the market. The difference between now and ten years ago, however, is that commission pricing and consumer preferences and expectations have changed dramatically. Online brokerages in 2021 have to work a lot harder to impress investors today than they did in 2011.

What is interesting about the latest launch by BMO InvestorLine are the “strings” attached to trading these commission-free ETFs. While the list of eligible ETFs is respectable at 80, there is a restriction that investors must hold the ETF for at least one business day from the date of purchase, which is bound to create some friction with some active users. Upon deeper reflection, however, it seems like the math still works out in BMO’s favour.

By implementing the “speed bump” on the timing between purchase and selling, the day traders are going to be excluded (for now). This implies the feature is targeting “investors” (or swing traders), and will almost certainly challenge National Bank Direct Brokerage’s approach of the required minimum buy

Directly challenging Qtrade Direct Investing and Scotia iTRADE will come down to other features and conveniences that BMO InvestorLine can offer clients. As such, it seems like a faceoff between Scotia iTRADE and BMO InvestorLine – but in a great move at the puck drop, BMO InvestorLine has posted a public statement about wait times on its website. This is a direct shot at Scotia iTRADE, which has suffered extended wait times on its phone lines for years, reaching almost unimaginable durations during the past year.

BMO InvestorLine is a large enough competitor to the steady state operations of both TD Direct Investing and RBC Direct Investing, that this latest move to include commission-free ETFs will not go unnoticed. It will also not go unnoticed by the Wealthsimple Trade crowd who find the lack of additional features or slow money transfer annoying at times.

Interestingly, at the time of publication, we had yet to see a big, splashy announcement, but that is almost certainly forthcoming. What BMO InvestorLine’s latest foray likely signals, however, is that one of the standard features an online brokerage needs to come to the table with in 2021 and beyond is ultra-low cost ETF trading.

While wishing for industry-wide dominos to fall might have been premature in 2011, even with a prominent bank-owned online broker getting into the mix, the famous last words of “it’s this different this time” ring true.

Most of the Canadian online brokerage field has managed to do just fine up until now without having to concede ground on commission-free ETFs, let alone commission-free trading. That said, treading water when it comes to pricing or innovation in features no longer feels like an option when the investor tide has clearly turned towards lower-priced alternatives.

Latest Canadian Online Rankings Point to Underwhelming Experiences for DIY Investors

If April showers bring May flowers, it seems like those showers also have brought with them a deluge of data on the DIY investing space in Canada, the US, and even around the world.

The latest landmark data release to launch (publicly) occurred last week, when J.D. Power released the 2021 edition of their Self-Directed Investor Satisfaction Study for Canadian online brokerages.

Now in its 13th year, this study measures “investor satisfaction” among Canadian DIY investors who are clients at a number of popular online brokerages. This year, as in the past few years, eight of 14 or so Canadian online brokerages were included in the analysis, providing a reasonably good approximation of the state of investor satisfaction among Canadian investors.

Of course, regular readers of the Roundup know what’s about to come next when talking about another data report on DIY investors or online investing: we have to dive into the methodology to understand what is being measured and better contextualize the findings.

Like many other online brokerage rankings we’ve covered recently, this year’s J.D. Power investor satisfaction study contains a rich source of insight about DIY investors. And, while the reporting format is fairly standard to its historical structure, what caught our eye this year were the important changes that were made to how investor satisfaction was defined.

Methodology and definition changes aside, it was fascinating to unpack the data on this year’s win, but also to contextualize this year’s results against the historical data from this survey. This has helped to really clarify who has been working hard to consistently improve, who has struggled in 2020/2021, and what the DIY investor can expect when it comes to online brokerages in Canada (hint: it’s not great).

What are the rankings about – what do they measure?

Before diving into the results, it’s extra important to spend some time reviewing the methodology and what’s changed about what this study measured in its latest edition.

According to the press release announcing the findings, there were 2,011 Canadian investors surveyed from December 2020 to February 2021 about their perspectives on various components of the online investing experience.

As mentioned in previous coverage of this study, the definition of “investor satisfaction” is made up of multiple components, and this year the factors that comprise that definition changed. The table below shows the seven components that “investor satisfaction” was measured against in 2020 and in 2021.

Change in Definition of Investor Satisfaction: 2020 vs 2021
20202021
Firm interaction (1)Trust (1)
Account information (2)Digital channels (2)
Commissions and fees (3)Ability to manage wealth how & when I want (3)
Product and service offerings (4)Products and services (4)
Information resources (5)Value for fees (5)
Investment performance (6)People (6)
Problem resolution (7)Problem resolution (7)

While there are a couple of components, such as products and services and problem resolution, that appear in the same level of priority in both frameworks, the rest of the changes point to a significant difference in the drivers of investor satisfaction.

At the top of the list for 2021, “Trust” is now the most important driver, followed by “Digital channels” and the “Ability to manage wealth how & where I want.” In 2021, pricing – as measured in “Value for fees” – falls to fifth from third place.

One of the important limitations of the published rankings is that they did not provide detailed definitions of what these terms refer to specifically. And, with a term like “trust” there could be many different interpretations of what that refers to. Nonetheless, there are some reasonable assumptions that can be made around most of what these categories refer to. The most important point to take note of is that the construct of “investor satisfaction” – or even which online brokerage is “best” – is highly dependent on how that is being measured.

DIY investors place different weights on the importance of each of these factors, so although this survey provides a systematic approach to comparing investor attitudes and beliefs about the online brokerage experience, individual investors are likely to have differing opinions on how well or poorly these results match their own experiences.

What are the findings from this year’s results?

With some important qualifiers out of the way, the results from this year’s study paint a portrait of an industry that has struggled to keep pace with the level of demand from DIY investors. Whether it was on the customer service front, where wait times and getting through to a human was nearly Sisyphean, or it was on platform stability on the most volatile of trading days (or some not-so-volatile days either), how online brokerages weathered the storm became evident through the data gathered in this study.  

Perhaps the most telling finding in this regard is that 24% of investors reported having at least one problem with their firm in the past 12 months, up from 14% in 2020 and more than double the rate in the US (11%). For active investors, this is a big problem when it comes to assessments around reliability. For less active investors, however, if the most “exciting” days to be in the market are fraught with outages, delays, or interruptions to service, there is almost no second chance to make a first impression.

And, according to additional findings in the data, those hiccups matter. 20% of investors who experienced a problem stated they are considering switching, which is more than three times the rate of those without issues who would consider switching online brokerages.

According to Michael Foy, Senior Director and Head of Wealth Intelligence at J.D. Power:

“Especially for newer clients, those who have not yet developed strong loyalty with these firms, who are more likely to leave if they have a bad experience. Investors today have more choices and firms need to raise the bar on the experience they deliver.”

Of course, beyond the contextual information, the focal point of the rankings is the list of how each online brokerage scored.  

National Bank Direct Brokerage654
Questrade645
RBC Direct Investing615
BMO InvestorLine607
Desjardins Online Brokerage599
TD Direct Investing591
CIBC Investor’s Edge585
Scotia iTRADE576

The table above shows the numerical scores achieved by Canadian online brokerages that were reported on for this study. The scoring for the online brokerage ranking by J.D. Power is out of 1,000, so it was interesting to note that this year the scores were lower on average than they have been historically (more on that in a moment).

The average score across the eight online brokerages that were reported on was 602. On an absolute basis, it is tricky to compare year over year results now that the evaluation criteria has dramatically shifted. However, on a relative basis, it is possible to derive additional insight.

One of the first things that is important to point out is the spread between first and last place. In this case, the distance between the top and bottom of the ranking is 78 points. By comparison, last year’s ranking saw a difference of only 33 points between top and bottom. It is therefore fair to say that volatility in this year’s rankings reflect some meaningful differences in the way online brokerage operations are impacting investor satisfaction.

The difference between first place ranked National Bank Direct Brokerage and second place Questrade was only nine points, but the difference between second and third place (RBC Direct Investing) was a whopping 30 points. What this implies is the top two firms substantially outperformed the remainder of their peers on the measures contained in this ranking.

Curiously, the difference between placements from third place onwards is a fairly consistent six to nine point drop. This linear decrease is probably an artifact of certain kinds of measures, but it implies that the bottom six online brokers could make significant strides on this index with a minimal amount of effort invested in customer satisfaction.

What is not a coincidence, however, is that five of the bottom six online brokerages in this ranking are the Big Five bank-owned Canadian online brokerages. The differentiating factors between these brokerages are minimal, so it stands to reason that investor satisfaction levels with these bank-owned online brokerages is probably pretty close too.

In contrast, the data from the latest online brokerage survey imply that the firms at the top have found the right mix of service and pricing with DIY investors in 2020, which has created a big gap between these firms and the rest.

National Bank Direct Brokerage and Questrade were able to do something very different and appealing for their clients, compared to the rest of the industry in 2020.

How do this year’s results stack up over time?

It’s at this point that historical data is incredibly helpful to provide additional context around online brokerage performance on the J.D. Power Investor Satisfaction rankings.

Analyzing the results from 2017 to 2021, one of the first things that immediately jumps out is that the average investor satisfaction scores with Canadian online brokerages, regardless of how they’re measured, have been decreasing.

Scores from J.D. Power Canadian Self-Directed Investor Study 2017 to 2021 (heatmaps applied to each year).

The stretch from 2020 to 2021 is an anomalous one in terms of customer composition for online brokerages because so many new investors have joined the client pool.

As the J.D. Power study pointed out, many of these new clients haven’t had the benefit of seeing what the experience was prior to this year. With the number of service and performance issues many online brokerages suffered from, the risk of new clients who joined an online brokerage leaving shortly after joining is likely higher than it’s been in the past.  

For DIY investors who have been around since 2016 (which is what the 2017 data would have captured) or earlier, J.D. Power’s satisfaction scores imply being a DIY investor has probably felt like an investment with diminishing returns at most of the brokerages analyzed. Even if pricing has become more competitive, the value proposition has not improved overall, at least in the firms whose data was published as part of this ranking.

Since not all online brokerages were reported on, it is hard to say what the DIY investor experience has been like at Qtrade Direct Investing or Interactive Brokers or even Wealthsimple Trade, names that are often associated with significant enthusiasm in either rankings or DIY investor community discussions.

Another remarkably consistent pattern that stands out with these rankings is not so much who’s at the top, but rather who has remained at or near the bottom.

In three of the past four years, Scotia iTRADE has ranked as the online brokerage with the least satisfied clients, with TD Direct Investing not too far behind. Historical data also shows that CIBC Investor’s Edge has gone from being among the top online brokerages as recently as 2019 to second last in 2021.

Looking back over the past five years, Questrade stands out as an online brokerage that has continuously strengthened its satisfaction scores, and although it dropped from top spot last year to second place this year, it continues to move in a positive direction for DIY investors, even under the new evaluation criteria. On a relative basis, RBC Direct Investing has gone from a consistently average score to one that is better than average.

Historical investor satisfaction data also helps to quickly spot online brokerages who had an especially rough year in terms of maintaining investor satisfaction.

Desjardins Online Brokerage, for example, went from a market leading (or high scoring) position from 2017 through 2020 to being below average in 2021. Another unusual score was BMO InvestorLine’s. Like Desjardins, BMO InvestorLine consistently placed at or near the top from 2017 through 2020, however for the 2021 results, BMO InvestorLine just barely beat the average.

As mentioned above, the changes in the methodology used to define investor satisfaction make comparing absolute scores from one year to the next hard to do, but the relative position of each of these Canadian online brokerages to one another makes it clear who the leaders and laggards are. Perhaps most compelling is that the bottom of the pool did not really change in 2020 and 2021 despite the shift in how things are being measured.

Takeaways

There are a number of very interesting takeaways from the latest online brokerage rankings by J.D. Power.

As other data points have indicated, most Canadian online brokerages were not ready for the crush of new business in the form of DIY investors wanting to sign up for new accounts, or for the flood of investor trading volume that came with it. What the J.D. Power satisfaction study helped put into sharper focus was the impact to firms via the voice of their customers.

The new methodology by the investor satisfaction study puts Trust at the top of the criteria that they now evaluate online brokerages with. In a world where pricing among online brokerages is increasingly under pressure, DIY investors are still going to expect that an online brokerage platform be reliable, and when pricing is high, so too are expectations around the ability to perform when needed.

National Bank Direct Brokerage appears to have figured out some key ingredients. Low commissions, and entirely free commission buying and selling are important on the pricing front, and whatever they happen to be doing on the service front is working as well.

The latest evaluation by Surviscor highlights the pricing advantage that National Bank Direct Brokerage offers relative to other brokerages, and National Bank Direct Brokerage is starting to gain traction in discussions on social media channels. With this additional accolade, the “trust” profile and the interest in National Bank Direct Brokerage is sure to grow.

According to the J.D. Power Investor Satisfaction Study, Canadian online investing satisfaction scores are nothing to write home about. The troubling trend the historical data has uncovered is that there is a palpable gap in innovation and enthusiasm to do better for clients. Compared to the US, most Canadian online brokerages are trailing in areas that are critical to building loyalty and client delight.

The opportunity to any Canadian online brokerage who reviews this data is that an extraordinary service or innovative experience can earn and win a lot of praise. As the saying goes, there is far less traffic on the extra mile, so firms doing more in either service or innovation are going to stand out (in a good way).

From the Forums

Riding the Commission-Free Waive

It’s hard to keep a deal this good a secret for long. Eagle-eyed DIY investors spotted a new commission-free ETF feature at BMO InvestorLine before any official announcement. Here are a few links of interest worth browsing:

BMO InvestorLine Now Offering Commission Free ETFs (reddit)

Zero Commission ETFs (Financial Wisdom Forum)

Commission Free ETFs at BMO Investorline (Red Flag Deals)

Commission-Free at Last

Is the grass (and account statement) really greener on the other side of the $10 commission per trade? One forum user sparked a lively discussion of DIY investors on the topic of switching away from paying higher fees for trading online. Read more about what users had to say here.

Into the Close

With US markets closed, there’s only one story that matters to many Canadian DIY investors – will the Leafs beat themselves? Ironically the last time the Toronto Maple Leafs were in the Stanley Cup playoffs was the same year Friends signed off, which was 2004. In 2021, it’s going to be debatable who had the bigger comeback.

Posted on by

Discount Brokerage Weekly Roundup – May 24, 2021

Stock markets in Canada were closed for Victoria Day, but that did little to dampen activity and enthusiasm for DIY investors looking stateside (or further afield) for trading opportunities. And they’re not alone. On the unofficial start to summer, we decided to peek across the (still-closed) border with the US to catch up on important trends and developments in the US online investing space.  

In this America-focused Weekly Roundup, we look at interesting developments among the biggest and smallest online brokerages in the US, and how each is shaping what DIY investors can expect from their online investing experience. First, we focus on the biggest player in the space, Schwab, and what some recent data released by them suggests about DIY investing enthusiasm. Next, we turn the spotlight onto another online investing player, tastytrade, who has demonstrated just how far enthusiasm and community can take an online trading brand. As always, we cap things off with some interesting DIY investor conversation to ease back into the shortened week (here in Canada).

Scaling New Heights: Lessons from Schwab After Peak YOLO

When it comes to online brokerages, there’s big, there’s bigger, then there’s Charles Schwab. Given its gargantuan size and diverse business activities, it’s almost a misnomer to characterize one of the original discount brokerages as such in 2021.

With banking activities, managed wealth, and a host of other financial services that go beyond online stock trading, online trading makes up a small fraction of where Schwab makes their money these days. Even so, given the number of accounts and reputation in the US online brokerage market, Schwab is undoubtedly an influential force with retail investors.

Just how big is Schwab?

Their recently reported trading metrics from April listed  total client assets as $7.34 trillion (USD), an increase of 4% from March and 94% from April 2020 (not a typo). At these levels, spreadsheet columns have to be widened to accommodate the number of digits in a cell to properly total things up. So, if there’s one measure to indicate that you’ve made it in the world, it might just be that.

One of the reasons that they continue to grow at such an extraordinary clip was also reported in Schwab’s latest performance report.

In April, Schwab opened 609,000 new online brokerage accounts (also not a typo), which is over three times what they opened in the same period last year (201,000 new accounts). By comparison, Interactive Brokers, another popular publicly traded US online brokerage, opened about 34,200 net new accounts in April – not an apples-to-apples comparison, but it does provide a reasonable approximation of the scale of difference between the two online brokerages.

While the snapshot of data is mind blowing on its own, when put into context across time, the account opening data at online brokerages like Schwab and Interactive Brokers reveal a possible trend forming: a peak in the surge of DIY investor interest.

Of specific importance is comparing the drops in new account openings at Schwab and Interactive Brokers as an indicator that the “fast money” active traders have stepped away from the online trading space in larger numbers than less active investors have. Thus, Interactive Brokers and firms that cater to active traders will have seen a stronger pullback than firms that cater to “average” DIY investors.

Consider the following: compared to March, the number of new accounts opened at Schwab in April was actually down 28%. By comparison, Interactive Brokers saw a drop of 43% in net new accounts on a month-over-month basis. At both brokerages, new account openings have declined double digits for the past two months, and in the case of Interactive Brokers, the declines in new account openings started in February.

What this data signals is that US online brokerages are seeing elevated account openings relative to last year but a rapidly declining rate of new account openings from retail investors in 2021. In short: the flood of DIY investors appears to have crested.

Due to COVID-19, 2020 and 2021 have been strange years to say the least. Even though a lot has already been written about the elevated interest in investing online, industry analysts have understood that a drop off was bound to occur at some point. The profile of that drop off, however, is starting to become more clear and that has implications for online brokerages during the transition back to a more normal economy.

With May just around the corner, the volume of new accounts will be an important indicator to watch to see if the contraction in account growth is accelerating or decelerating.

Regardless of the direction of new account sign ups, the data on total accounts opened at online brokerages reveals an unmistakable feature: there are lots of new investors who decided to open up online investing and trading accounts in 2021 – a fact that is all the more impressive considering the surge in interest in online investing by investors last year at about the same time.

The question confronting online brokerages such as Schwab and Interactive Brokers is: will these new investors will stick around?

Some important clues to answering that question came from the spring business update presented by Schwab in late April this year.

One important data point (hooray, more data) is that 70% of clients new to Schwab’s retail trading business in the first quarter of 2021 were under the age of 40. Demographically, this sets the stage for long-term retention if the client experience and value proposition are in place to properly cater to this group of investors.

The strongest statement regarding the outcome of the increased interest by newer investors is seen in the slide shown above. Schwab expects retaining clients, and their assets, even if trading activity levels decrease as markets stabilize.

It is this forecast that spells out one the most important strengths of having the kind of scale that Schwab does. With that kind of size, even small percentage improvements in revenue generating activities can tremendously impact the bottom line.

For example, two trends on the above slide show that retail trades per account have more than tripled from December 2019 to March 2021, and that margin balances as a percentage of total client assets have also increased from 0.7% in Q4 2019 to 1.0% in Q1 2021.

A recent promotional email received from Interactive Brokers helps to illustrate why margin loans trending up at Schwab is so important: the margin loan rates at Schwab are substantially higher than at Interactive Brokers.

Thus, the interesting (no pun intended) picture emerging is that for the new investors who joined Schwab and who are going to be more actively trading, an almost 5x cost differential in margin lending rates is going to matter at some point. In case you’re curious, the margin lending rate at Robinhood is 2.5% at the time of publication, which underscores just how fiercely competitive Interactive Brokers is when it comes to features that typically appeal to active traders.

The challenge for Schwab, and really any online brokerage that wants to generate revenues in a zero-commission model, is to charge more for other features, like margin interest, to offset the forgone revenue from trading commission.

For Canadian online brokerages, margin interest rates are a feature that appeal to active investors or investors with larger assets who don’t trade as frequently but who use margin. Both these segments represent high value clients to an online brokerage, so rather than dropping commission rates to zero, savvy online brokerages in Canada may provide attractive margin rates in order to win new clients (or retain existing ones).

The US online brokerage market is fiercely competitive in many respects, however, because they have largely moved to a “zero-commission” world there are other aspects of their business, such as margin rates, that mainstream online brokerages have been slower to compete on. Here in Canada, where zero-dollar commission trading is not really prevalent, margin rates seem like an interesting area to watch.

As was mentioned last week in our coverage of Surviscor’s analysis of pricing among Canadian online brokerages, there is no such thing as a “free lunch,” and as a result, DIY investors can expect to pay the price for commission-free trades in other parts of the online trading experience.

The key takeaway from the latest set of data indicators at Schwab are that there is now a large cohort of online investors who have opened up online investing accounts, who will likely be in need of a very different kind of investing experience going forward than what spurred them to be interested to begin with. If the “fast money” has exited, and markets have less volatility, active traders are going to be hard pressed to find compelling trading opportunities – which is a need almost all brokerages will have an interest in trying to address regardless of size.

The Power of Small: Tastytrade Built a Billion-Dollar Business on Community

This past week, the online financial media powerhouse tastytrade celebrated an impressive milestone: their 10 year anniversary. As part of that accomplishment, they released a very interesting documentary that profiled how the tastytrade brand was conceived, launched, and has grown over the past decade.

The documentary is fascinating content on a number of levels. From the background of how the company came to be named after a popular Philadelphia-area snack, to the palpable enthusiasm for doing something different in finance, the video captures the journey of the tastytrade brand through their first 10 years and ends with an intriguing view of trading in the future.

What is most compelling about this documentary, however, is that it showcases how a powerhouse online investing brand can develop by focusing first on delivering engaging, people-centred content.

It helps to understand that one of the founders behind tastytrade is Tom Sosnoff, the founder of the ultra-popular options trading platform Thinkorswim. Thinkorswim was eventually acquired by Ameritrade (which was then acquired by TD, and the resulting entity, TD Ameritrade, was eventually acquired by Schwab). Thus, the roots of tastytrade’s success in talking in-depth about trading options trace back to Sosnoff’s pioneering work with the Thinkorswim platform.

In the documentary, Sosnoff’s journey from Thinkorswim to tastystrade helps to explain a lot about how the core team that started tastytrade came together, and more importantly, the fact that the focus behind tastytrade was to build financial content in a way that was as much entertaining as it was useful.

Really interesting financial content, it seems, is in very limited supply. And as a result, the business model for tastytrade appeared to be to create an audience of individuals who are interested in and educated about options trading, and that would ultimately set the stage for the online brokerage arm, tastyworks, to translate that viewership into clientele.

As with many great entrepreneurial endeavours, the founders of tastytrade didn’t envision exactly where the business would get to. The billion-dollar acquisition of tastytrade in January of this year, however, validated the premise that building an engaging platform to help investors navigate the world of investing – including something as complex as options trading – would be of real value.

Another very interesting facet of the documentary is the way in which the tastytrade “secret sauce” came together.  

Perhaps it was the comfort level with risk that naturally accompanies a lifelong trader, but the idea to staff a financial content company with comedians to deliver financial information is anything but traditional. In fact, what is genuinely interesting to witness over the journey of the past ten years, is the constant level of experimentation with different types of shows and formats that inevitably has led tastytrade to where it is today – being able to generate live programming seven days a week, having over 100 shows, and a growing global audience (the stat shared about audience cited over 100 million hours of views) reaching 190 countries.

Ultimately, the winning set of ingredients for programming on tastytrade came down to having an authentic interaction between traders and the not-yet-trader staff captured in real time.

Having Sosnoff and co-host walk the talk about their trade ideas and strategies, engage in random banter, and do so in a down-to-earth fashion tapped into the DIY investor culture in a way that traditional news media or traditional approaches to financial content never quite got right. Before podcasting exploded, Sosnoff sought a radio-show feel to the tastytrade core programming, and as a result of a lot of trial and error, the end result was understanding how best to deliver the message through various media.

Although shows are planned and professionally produced, they don’t feel overly scripted. There is visible diversity and a tangible enthusiasm for either learning about trading, or teaching trading, or just talking about trading (or the things that traders would inevitably talk about in the news). In short, Sosnoff and the tastytrade team nailed the culture of trading, because many of those planning or participating in shows have been a part of that world for so long.

This is not unlike the approach of Thomas Peterffy during his tenure as CEO of Interactive Brokers. Like Peterffy, Sosnoff understands the mindset of traders, and to his credit surrounded himself with a team that has created a very loyal and vocal community of traders/viewers (aka tastynation).

For online brokerages in Canada – and likely the world over at this point – there is an inescapable reality about the business: order execution is not enough. What tastytrade and tastyworks clearly demonstrate is that self-directed investors need both education in the form of navigating strategies and principles related to investing, as well as trading ideas. And, as any patient spouse or family member of an avid DIY investor will attest to, self-directed investors also need what other humans need, connection and community. And, tastytrade offers the latter in large measure.

Instead of analyst reports and the traditional news feed of financial data, tastytrade has shown that taking a human-centred approach makes financial content more accessible. And they’re not alone. Robinhood understood this with their purchase of the podcast Market Snacks (now Robinhood Snacks), a financial content show that provides updates on popular market stories and publicly traded companies. Regular (i.e. daily) content with personality that audiences can develop relationships with build and drive loyalty. It compels people to tune in, and in turn, feel more comfortable and even confident in taking on trading ideas they hear being discussed.

Despite the regulatory hurdles in Canada that constrain how much in-house content can be created at an online brokerage, tastytrade and other online brokerages in the US have shown that the formula for success and client delight is enhanced with compelling and delightful content.

As of right now, there is no clear DIY investor content leader among Canadian online brokerages. However, sometime in the not-too-distant future that may change. Tastytrade and tastyworks have publicly telegraphed their intent to come to Canada, and when they do, it will be a challenge for any online broker here to compete against that human-centred content machine.

It’s already clear that certain online brokerages are trying to generate “investing” content. Simply creating content and having it available on different channels, however, is a brute-force way to get attention on content. While it might “work” in the short term, it is highly transactional and not at all a part of what human investors ultimately seek – which is community and connection.

Although coming to Canada is not mentioned directly in the documentary, where tastytrade plans to go next is equally fascinating.

Now part of a much larger global brand, if tastytrade can retain and direct much of what has contributed to their success to date, the technologically immersive experience of online investing previewed in the video reiterates just how much trading culture and community is at the heart of the growth strategy. Ironically, or perhaps expertly, tastytrade has demonstrated the ability to grow exponentially bigger by focusing on creating the feeling of being small.

From the Forums

Gearing Up for Leverage

Making decisions to trade using margin or leverage is not something to be taken lightly. Looking to the wisdom of crowds, one young investor taps into the online investing opinions of reddit for perspective on whether or not leverage is worth doing with a secured line of credit. Read what redditors had to say here.

Minding Your Own Business

Trading online as an individual is one thing, but getting a corporate account to trade online with can be surprisingly personal. One online investor turned to other investors for guidance on whether the assurances sought by one online brokerage for a corporate trading account were, in fact, appropriate. Find out more here.

Into the Close

That’s a wrap on the long-weekend edition of the Roundup. With so much of the focus of this Roundup on the US, there is another important and sombre milestone in the US taking place this week: the one year anniversary of the murder of George Floyd. There has been a lot of heavy-hearted news over the past year, however, one thing that is clear is that we can all play a part in eradicating racial injustice and discrimination. If you’ve found your way to this part of the Roundup, take a few moments to reflect on or read about racial injustice. There’s also a simple but powerful film on the topic below.